Corsair CMX512-3200XL on A8N-SLI Premium??
in [Asus]
|
From: milleron on 18 Nov 2005 16:15 I built my A8N-SLI Premium system back in June using TwinX 1024 PC3200XLPT DIMMs. I set the command rate to 1T, and everything was OK for about 4 months. I had a funny crash in October that reset a BIOS setting for the boot order of the SATA drives, and I ended up reinstalling XP. I kept getting BSODs after that with a variety of messages that, taken together, seemed to incriminate RAM. I went through three weeks of troubleshooting, finally installing a single stick of Corsair ValueSelect VS512-400. Neither stick of the original 3200XLPT, installed singly, would run Prime95's Torture Test for more than a few seconds. The much less expensive ValueSelect runs it just fine, even with the command rate set to 1T. The Corsair Web site indicates that the CMX512-3200XLPT modules are compatible with this motherboard. I find it difficult to believe that both of them would have gone bad after I installed them, though, so I wonder (the BIG QUESTION) if anyone else has found a compatibility problem with them on this motherboard. Ron
From: Mark A on 19 Nov 2005 06:05 "milleron" <millerdot90(a)SPAMLESSosu.edu> wrote in message news:kigsn15cel68mot8vjlthqck5h9hq68jl1(a)4ax.com... >I built my A8N-SLI Premium system back in June using TwinX 1024 > PC3200XLPT DIMMs. I set the command rate to 1T, and everything was OK > for about 4 months. I had a funny crash in October that reset a BIOS > setting for the boot order of the SATA drives, and I ended up > reinstalling XP. > > I kept getting BSODs after that with a variety of messages that, taken > together, seemed to incriminate RAM. I went through three weeks of > troubleshooting, finally installing a single stick of Corsair > ValueSelect VS512-400. Neither stick of the original 3200XLPT, > installed singly, would run Prime95's Torture Test for more than a few > seconds. The much less expensive ValueSelect runs it just fine, even > with the command rate set to 1T. > > The Corsair Web site indicates that the CMX512-3200XLPT modules are > compatible with this motherboard. I find it difficult to believe that > both of them would have gone bad after I installed them, though, so I > wonder (the BIG QUESTION) if anyone else has found a compatibility > problem with them on this motherboard. > > Ron The Forum on the Corsair website provides information for the timings and voltage that should be used for each model of memory.
From: Phil DeBecker on 19 Nov 2005 11:40 On Fri, 18 Nov 2005 21:15:48 GMT, milleron <millerdot90(a)SPAMLESSosu.edu> wrote: >I built my A8N-SLI Premium system back in June using TwinX 1024 >PC3200XLPT DIMMs. I set the command rate to 1T, and everything was OK >for about 4 months. I had a funny crash in October that reset a BIOS >setting for the boot order of the SATA drives, and I ended up >reinstalling XP. > >I kept getting BSODs after that with a variety of messages that, taken >together, seemed to incriminate RAM. I went through three weeks of >troubleshooting, finally installing a single stick of Corsair >ValueSelect VS512-400. Neither stick of the original 3200XLPT, >installed singly, would run Prime95's Torture Test for more than a few >seconds. The much less expensive ValueSelect runs it just fine, even >with the command rate set to 1T. > >The Corsair Web site indicates that the CMX512-3200XLPT modules are >compatible with this motherboard. I find it difficult to believe that >both of them would have gone bad after I installed them, though, so I >wonder (the BIG QUESTION) if anyone else has found a compatibility >problem with them on this motherboard. > >Ron I'm using a TWINX1024-3200XL kit, which is two CMX512-3200XL DIMMs. They run stable at the default settings in my A8N-SLI Premium, but if I want to run them at 2.0-2-2-5 1T I have to up the DIMM voltage to 2.8. The Corsair website indicates that these DIMMs are warrantied to 2.9 volts, so it's safe to run them at that voltage, and the site says that 2.8 is the recommended voltage for these DIMMs at that speed. It sort of sounds like something happened to your original DIMMs, though, if they suddenly stopped working. It's difficult to think of a scenario that could fry both of your DIMMs and yet leave your motherboard undamaged, though.
From: milleron on 21 Nov 2005 00:13 On Sat, 19 Nov 2005 16:40:49 GMT, Phil DeBecker <in_a_coma_dial_999(a)yahoo.com> wrote: >On Fri, 18 Nov 2005 21:15:48 GMT, milleron ><millerdot90(a)SPAMLESSosu.edu> wrote: > >>I built my A8N-SLI Premium system back in June using TwinX 1024 >>PC3200XLPT DIMMs. I set the command rate to 1T, and everything was OK >>for about 4 months. I had a funny crash in October that reset a BIOS >>setting for the boot order of the SATA drives, and I ended up >>reinstalling XP. >> >>I kept getting BSODs after that with a variety of messages that, taken >>together, seemed to incriminate RAM. I went through three weeks of >>troubleshooting, finally installing a single stick of Corsair >>ValueSelect VS512-400. Neither stick of the original 3200XLPT, >>installed singly, would run Prime95's Torture Test for more than a few >>seconds. The much less expensive ValueSelect runs it just fine, even >>with the command rate set to 1T. >> >>The Corsair Web site indicates that the CMX512-3200XLPT modules are >>compatible with this motherboard. I find it difficult to believe that >>both of them would have gone bad after I installed them, though, so I >>wonder (the BIG QUESTION) if anyone else has found a compatibility >>problem with them on this motherboard. >> >>Ron > >I'm using a TWINX1024-3200XL kit, which is two CMX512-3200XL DIMMs. >They run stable at the default settings in my A8N-SLI Premium, but if >I want to run them at 2.0-2-2-5 1T I have to up the DIMM voltage to >2.8. The Corsair website indicates that these DIMMs are warrantied to >2.9 volts, so it's safe to run them at that voltage, and the site says >that 2.8 is the recommended voltage for these DIMMs at that speed. > >It sort of sounds like something happened to your original DIMMs, >though, if they suddenly stopped working. It's difficult to think of >a scenario that could fry both of your DIMMs and yet leave your >motherboard undamaged, though. Thanks very much for the info. I'm gratified to know that someone's having success with identical RAM True. Like I said, I found it hard to believe that both would go bad, but neither of them will run Prime95 for more than a few minutes whereas the inexpensive ValueSelect RAM will run it all day. I'm starting to think that they were bad from the start but that it became obvious when the OS got so many programs loaded that some of them started stressing the RAM more than when the computer was first put together a few months ago. BTW, I had LONG conversations with Ram Guy on the Corsair forum. I did have the voltage increased to 2.8 and then to 2.9, but even at the relaxed timings the BIOS defaulted to -- i.e., withOUT trying to get anywhere near 2-2-2-5 -- it still couldn't run Windows or Prime95 with stability. Ron
|
Pages: 1 Prev: ERROR, cant find system BIOS hook Next: asus pc probe problem |