From: Rajiv Sharma Rajiv on
Out of these two, which is used for calculating SPI ?

"Jim Aksel" wrote:

> %Complete is a duration based measure of complete. A 10 day task is 60%
> complete on day 6.
>
> %Work Complete claims against the amount of work loaded into a task. If the
> work is level loaded (same number of hours/day) then %Complete and %Work
> Complete essentially accomplish the same thing.
>
> Here is a more complex example. Two workers are assigned to a 10 day task.
> The work is loaded as 8 hours/day for the first week and 1 hour/day for the
> second week. Total work is 45 hours. for convenience Worker1 works the first
> week, Worker2 works the second week. On day 6 the task is 60% Complete for
> duration, but is 41/45 (91%) Work Complete, assuming only one worker per day
> on the task.
>
> Try this, do some research on Physical%Complete as well. It relates a
> little more to the value produced. For our example above, suppose we assign
> two workers to the task. The first week Worker1 works at $30/hour for 40
> hours. The following week Worker2 is a consultant at $125/hr and he works
> the second week (alone). The total value of the task is 10 days, 45 hours,
> $1825 (40*30+5*125). On day 6, assuming everyone accomplished what they are
> supposed to: Physical%Complete goes to ($1200+$125)/$1825 = 73% . To use
> this technique you need costed resources and a baseline. I know this was
> beyond your question, so post back if you need additional guidance.
> --
> If this post was helpful, please consider rating it.
>
> Jim Aksel, MVP
>
> Check out my blog for more information:
> http://www.msprojectblog.com
>
>
>
> "neostar77" wrote:
>
> > What is the difference between using % complete and % work complete columns?
> >
> > What are the major impacts and limitations of using each?
From: G�rard Ducouret on
Rajiv,

None,
The SPI is calculated according to the formula :
SPI = BCWP / BCWS

G�rrad Ducouret

"Rajiv Sharma" <Rajiv Sharma(a)discussions.microsoft.com> a �crit dans le
message de news: 9B3DE00B-3137-49D6-82AB-4B29CC65D1B6(a)microsoft.com...
> Out of these two, which is used for calculating SPI ?
>
> "Jim Aksel" wrote:
>
>> %Complete is a duration based measure of complete. A 10 day task is 60%
>> complete on day 6.
>>
>> %Work Complete claims against the amount of work loaded into a task. If
>> the
>> work is level loaded (same number of hours/day) then %Complete and %Work
>> Complete essentially accomplish the same thing.
>>
>> Here is a more complex example. Two workers are assigned to a 10 day
>> task.
>> The work is loaded as 8 hours/day for the first week and 1 hour/day for
>> the
>> second week. Total work is 45 hours. for convenience Worker1 works the
>> first
>> week, Worker2 works the second week. On day 6 the task is 60% Complete
>> for
>> duration, but is 41/45 (91%) Work Complete, assuming only one worker per
>> day
>> on the task.
>>
>> Try this, do some research on Physical%Complete as well. It relates a
>> little more to the value produced. For our example above, suppose we
>> assign
>> two workers to the task. The first week Worker1 works at $30/hour for 40
>> hours. The following week Worker2 is a consultant at $125/hr and he
>> works
>> the second week (alone). The total value of the task is 10 days, 45
>> hours,
>> $1825 (40*30+5*125). On day 6, assuming everyone accomplished what they
>> are
>> supposed to: Physical%Complete goes to ($1200+$125)/$1825 = 73% . To
>> use
>> this technique you need costed resources and a baseline. I know this was
>> beyond your question, so post back if you need additional guidance.
>> --
>> If this post was helpful, please consider rating it.
>>
>> Jim Aksel, MVP
>>
>> Check out my blog for more information:
>> http://www.msprojectblog.com
>>
>>
>>
>> "neostar77" wrote:
>>
>> > What is the difference between using % complete and % work complete
>> > columns?
>> >
>> > What are the major impacts and limitations of using each?