From: Bart Van der Donck on
Hans-Georg Michna wrote:

>> www.ajax-cross-domain.com
>
> Why the unnecessary complexity of a Perl server service? Why not
> simply use a very light proxy server, as shown in
> http://winhlp.com/node/699?

In so far I see, Ajax Cross Domain would use the same mechanism as
your JSP/PHP, but then done in Perl: grab URI, perform request, return
response. I think this is a dead simple principle; in my opinion not
complex at all; the elaboration might look complex if the environment/
technology is unknown, like e.g. I would find your solution more
difficult, because I am unfamiliar with JSP and PHP.

I agree that Ajax Cross Domain could be considered as a server (as any
CGI/PHP/ASP/...?), but I would rather look at it as a regular script,
a bit in the tradition of all those ancient content-grabbers, but then
then in a modern ajaxy coat.

> To provide such a service for the public is nice, but would it
> stand up to worldwide use? Probably not. People would have to
> set up their own services, and then I fail to see the advantage
> over a simple proxy server.

I'm quite positive that scripts like Ajax Cross Domain reflect a real
need, but you're absolutely right that multiple good solutions
available.

Cheers,

--
Bart