From: Ian Piper on
Hi all,

I have a weird problem with my MBP today. It was showing some problems
with starting up MAMP, so I decided to reboot. On startup I got the
grey screen with a dark grey no entry sign (circle with a diagonal
line through it) and it went no further. I could start it up in safe
mode, though it took longer obviously. It even started MAMP OK once
booted, which knocked on the head my initial theory about that being
the cause.

Has anyone come across something similar? Given that it starts in safe
mode but not in normal mode, is there anywhere obvious that I could
look for the source of the problem?

I've recently updated to 10.6.3 and installed the latest security
update.


Ian.
--
From: Jaimie Vandenbergh on
On Fri, 23 Apr 2010 04:51:47 -0700 (PDT), Ian Piper
<ianpiper(a)gmail.com> wrote:

>Hi all,
>
>I have a weird problem with my MBP today. It was showing some problems
>with starting up MAMP, so I decided to reboot. On startup I got the
>grey screen with a dark grey no entry sign (circle with a diagonal
>line through it) and it went no further. I could start it up in safe
>mode, though it took longer obviously. It even started MAMP OK once
>booted, which knocked on the head my initial theory about that being
>the cause.
>
>Has anyone come across something similar? Given that it starts in safe
>mode but not in normal mode, is there anywhere obvious that I could
>look for the source of the problem?
>
>I've recently updated to 10.6.3 and installed the latest security
>update.

Usually indicative of not being able to start the boot process from
anything. Might be a sign of incipient HD failure, so make sure your
backups are up to date right now. Might just be an odd effect with the
EFI not being able to find your boot partition.

Then reboot to the install DVD (or a spare bootable disk) and run Disk
Utility and repair the boot disk. This might fix it if it's just a
partition format fault.

It won't be MAMP, but it might be a problem tickled by the 10.6.3
update - is this the first reboot since then?

Cheers - Jaimie
--
None of this will matter in 20 billion years.
From: Ian Piper on
On Apr 23, 1:31 pm, Jaimie Vandenbergh <jai...(a)sometimes.sessile.org>
wrote:

> Usually indicative of not being able to start the boot process from
> anything. Might be a sign of incipient HD failure, so make sure your
> backups are up to date right now. Might just be an odd effect with the
> EFI not being able to find your boot partition.
>
> Then reboot to the install DVD (or a spare bootable disk) and run Disk
> Utility and repair the boot disk. This might fix it if it's just a
> partition format fault.
>
> It won't be MAMP, but it might be a problem tickled by the 10.6.3
> update - is this the first reboot since then?

I wondered about whether this meant a looming disk problem. Irritating
since I had to replace a disk on my wife's iMac just a few weeks ago
(though in that case I saw a flashing folder/question mark icon - in
all my Mac years I have never seen a no entry icon!).

I have another partition on that disk so I set that as the boot
partition, started up fine and ran Disk Warrior against the non-
booting partition. It found a few directory problems but the SMART
status was fine and there were no permissions or other problems. I
accepted the directory fixes, restarted on that partition and it still
says "no entry". It feels to me as though this is a minor driver or
other incompatibility, but I'm not sure how to check that - could
there be odd startup items that are disabled in safe boot? That might
explain why it boots one way but not the other. Is there a technical
explanation somewhere that sets out exactly what safe boot does? I
have checked the Apple KB but could find no details, alas.

However the machine is still in warranty, so if I can't resolve this
I'll be on the blower to Apple. I do have TM backups up to this
morning, so it won't be a total disaster if the disk dies.


Ian.
--
From: Jaimie Vandenbergh on
On Fri, 23 Apr 2010 07:08:59 -0700 (PDT), Ian Piper
<ianpiper(a)gmail.com> wrote:

>On Apr 23, 1:31�pm, Jaimie Vandenbergh <jai...(a)sometimes.sessile.org>
>wrote:
>
>> Usually indicative of not being able to start the boot process from
>> anything. Might be a sign of incipient HD failure, so make sure your
>> backups are up to date right now. Might just be an odd effect with the
>> EFI not being able to find your boot partition.
>>
>> Then reboot to the install DVD (or a spare bootable disk) and run Disk
>> Utility and repair the boot disk. This might fix it if it's just a
>> partition format fault.
>>
>> It won't be MAMP, but it might be a problem tickled by the 10.6.3
>> update - is this the first reboot since then?
>
>I wondered about whether this meant a looming disk problem. Irritating
>since I had to replace a disk on my wife's iMac just a few weeks ago
>(though in that case I saw a flashing folder/question mark icon - in
>all my Mac years I have never seen a no entry icon!).
>
>I have another partition on that disk so I set that as the boot
>partition, started up fine and ran Disk Warrior against the non-
>booting partition. It found a few directory problems but the SMART
>status was fine and there were no permissions or other problems. I
>accepted the directory fixes, restarted on that partition and it still
>says "no entry". It feels to me as though this is a minor driver or
>other incompatibility,

Maybe the 10.6.3 update didn't apply fully? Boot up on your other
partition and apply the combo update to the dubious one.

The other thing is that it may be a partition table error, and to use
Disk Utility to check for that I think you need to boot off an
entirely different device rather than another partition on the same
disk. The install DVD, for example.

Cheers - Jaimie
--
207 BC: Chrysippus, Greek stoic philosopher, is believed to have died of
laughter after watching his drunken donkey attempt to eat figs.
From: Rowland McDonnell on
Ian Piper <ianpiper(a)gmail.com> wrote:

> Hi all,
>
> I have a weird problem with my MBP today. It was showing some problems
> with starting up MAMP, so I decided to reboot. On startup I got the
> grey screen with a dark grey no entry sign (circle with a diagonal
> line through it) and it went no further. I could start it up in safe
> mode, though it took longer obviously. It even started MAMP OK once
> booted, which knocked on the head my initial theory about that being
> the cause.
>
> Has anyone come across something similar? Given that it starts in safe
> mode but not in normal mode, is there anywhere obvious that I could
> look for the source of the problem?
>
> I've recently updated to 10.6.3 and installed the latest security
> update.

Updates can cause booting problems. Things get screwed up. Hell, I've
found that re-booting has caused me reliability problems that have
persisted until I've run various maintenance jobs.

Others have said sensible thigns on the subject. My thoughts are:

I'd suspect the software update first, and then I'd worry that maybe it
was a hardware failure if it happened again without the coincidence of
just after a software update.

Anyway, I had iffiness after installing 10.6.3 (not big iffiness) and
rather more iffiness after installing the recent ARA update.

So I ran Onyx, checked the HD volume structures with it, ditto
permissions, it fixed a lot of duff permissions, checked prefs (no
trouble), flushed caches, re-booted a couple of times before logging on,
problems all gone.

Strangeness: one problem that turned up after installing the ARA update
was trouble mounting disc images. This problem vanished after the above
maintenance jobs. I've seen that problem before and it's gone away the
same way before - dunno what caused it.

--
Remove the animal for email address: rowland.mcdonnell(a)dog.physics.org
Sorry - the spam got to me
http://www.mag-uk.org http://www.bmf.co.uk
UK biker? Join MAG and the BMF and stop the Eurocrats banning biking