Prev: God doesn't play dice: cause and effect
Next: Mud Wrestling Mother's Day '10
From: Y.Porat on 10 May 2010 02:24
Let me start with a clarification:

i accept completely (with some clarifications)
the SR (special relativity)
i recognize Einstein s great contribution
about the photoelectric effect !!

yet i have big doubts about his gambling about
'curved space time'

and now to my doubts:

according to him and his followers
if we take for example the sun and earth case

The sun curves all space around it proportional to
its mass

the Earth moving around it does the same
but in a smaller scale (smaller curvature ?
bigger curvature ?? i guess bigger curvature ??)

now lets take another planet
which is bigger mass
so that bigger mass should orbit in another radius
it means that
THERE IS SOME 'INFORMATION EXCHANGE**
BETWEEN SUN AND ITS SATELLITES!!

my question is
WHAT IS THAT 'INFORMATION EXCHANGE ??!!
(between sun and satellite and how ??)
2
people talk about 'GRAVITONS'
what is the relation between Gravitons and
curved space??
or else no connection at all ??!!

TIA
Y.Porat
------------------------------






From: John Jones on 10 May 2010 09:02
Y.Porat wrote:
> Let me start with a clarification:
>
> i accept completely (with some clarifications)
> the SR (special relativity)
> i recognize Einstein s great contribution
> about the photoelectric effect !!
>
> yet i have big doubts about his gambling about
> 'curved space time'
>
> and now to my doubts:
>
> according to him and his followers
> if we take for example the sun and earth case
>
> The sun curves all space around it proportional to
> its mass
>
> the Earth moving around it does the same
> but in a smaller scale (smaller curvature ?
> bigger curvature ?? i guess bigger curvature ??)
>
> now lets take another planet
> which is bigger mass
> so that bigger mass should orbit in another radius
> it means that
> THERE IS SOME 'INFORMATION EXCHANGE**
> BETWEEN SUN AND ITS SATELLITES!!
>
> my question is
> WHAT IS THAT 'INFORMATION EXCHANGE ??!!
> (between sun and satellite and how ??)
> 2
> people talk about 'GRAVITONS'
> what is the relation between Gravitons and
> curved space??
> or else no connection at all ??!!
>
> TIA
> Y.Porat
> ------------------------------
>
>
>
>
>
>

doyoufindexcessivepunctuationtiring?
From: G. L. Bradford on 10 May 2010 14:25

"Y.Porat" <y.y.porat(a)gmail.com> wrote in message
news:8ee5a591-b1ac-4088-8cb1-827d110d9dec(a)g21g2000yqk.googlegroups.com...
> Let me start with a clarification:
>
> i accept completely (with some clarifications)
> the SR (special relativity)
> i recognize Einstein s great contribution
> about the photoelectric effect !!
>
> yet i have big doubts about his gambling about
> 'curved space time'
>
> and now to my doubts:
>
> according to him and his followers
> if we take for example the sun and earth case
>
> The sun curves all space around it proportional to
> its mass
>
> the Earth moving around it does the same
> but in a smaller scale (smaller curvature ?
> bigger curvature ?? i guess bigger curvature ??)
>
> now lets take another planet
> which is bigger mass
> so that bigger mass should orbit in another radius
> it means that
> THERE IS SOME 'INFORMATION EXCHANGE**
> BETWEEN SUN AND ITS SATELLITES!!
>
> my question is
> WHAT IS THAT 'INFORMATION EXCHANGE ??!!
> (between sun and satellite and how ??)
> 2
> people talk about 'GRAVITONS'
> what is the relation between Gravitons and
> curved space??
> or else no connection at all ??!!
>
> TIA
> Y.Porat
> ------------------------------
==================

Event horizon.

GLB

==================

 | 
Pages: 1
Prev: God doesn't play dice: cause and effect
Next: Mud Wrestling Mother's Day '10