From: Anonymous on
Bear Bottoms wrote:

> DissidentArmy <dissidentarmy(a)dissidentarmyNOT.invalid> wrote in
> news:4c42ea0a$1_3(a)news4us.nl:
>
>> On Sun, 18 Jul 2010 10:07:51 +0000, Bear Bottoms wrote:
>>
>>> DissidentArmy <dissidentarmy(a)dissidentarmyNOT.invalid> wrote in
>>> news:4c42cf8e$1_3(a)news4us.nl:
>>>
>>>> The fact that Rising is on it makes the statement Best Security List
>>>> in the World unbelievable.
>>>
>>> The fact that Rising is on the list corroborates my deductions about
>>> the program and demonstrates how little you actually know.
>>
>> The fact that Rising is nowhere mentioned on sites that are known for
>> their expertise in AV as good proves only that you've found the
>> exception that confirms the rule.
>>
> And a pretty damn good one also.

Baloney. Your "list" is a hack job.

From: Mike Easter on
Bear Bottoms wrote:

> I've done and am still doing the best test of all...actual use. I had it
> on my machine for almost two years and it performed better than those you
> tout...by far. I only removed it when MSE came out which is better IMO. I
> did not take it off of my wife's computer, as she is staying malware free
> for over two years. After I had to clean her very badly infected machine
> from her bad browsing habits a good while back, I installed Rising on it.
> She has been good ever since.

I think your personal experience and knowledge about Rising supports
your personal opinion argument.

I think the site/list we are talking about might have its name
misinterpreted by many people.

The *list* name is "Probably the Best Free Security List in the World"

What is good (not saying best or probably best) about the site is how
*extensive* its list is, not how *selective* its list is.

It is a free (to read) list, not a list of free software; the free
software is software positioned higher above payware in each sublist.

The listings and sub-listings themselves are 'massive'- 25 sections
containing a couple of hundred items, the blog commentary on the lists
is also huge, going back over a year.

The big site is maintained by volunteers. The volunteer currently
responsible for maintaining this specific list has been active on the
site for 24 months - but he is keeping the listings fresh and up to date.

The fact that Rising appears on two of the lists is not a credit to
Rising, because the list isn't a 'best of' the various categories except
when the volunteer flags it as his favorite, which he didn't do with
Rising's.

It may be significant that unlike the negative commentary about Rising's
apps here, there was no negative commentary at the site in the 5 pages
of commentary over the past year.

--
Mike Easter
From: Gordon Darling on
On Sun, 18 Jul 2010 22:53:56 +0000, Bear Bottoms wrote:

> Mike is one of the few intelligent people in this group. You aren't one
> of them.

And you're a cretin.





--
ox·y·mo·ron
n. pl. ox·y·mo·ra or ox·y·mo·rons
A rhetorical figure in which incongruous or contradictory terms are
combined, as in Microsoft Security, Microsoft Help and Microsoft Works.