From: Inertial on

"Inertial" <relatively(a)rest.com> wrote in message
news:4bac2e36$0$8840$c3e8da3(a)news.astraweb.com...
> Porat, Can you answer these questions honestly and without resorting to
> unwarranted and unprovoked personal attacks?
>
> You claim individual single photon energy is time dependent. What IS the
> dependency you claim between individual single photon energy and time
> duration .. is the energy:
> a) linearly proportional to the time (ie E = kt, for some constant k) ?
> b) proportional to the square of the time (ie E = kt^2, for some constant
> k) ?
> c) inversely proportional (ie E = k/t, for some constant k) ?
> d) none of the above (please provide the relationship in formula form)
>
> Next .. consider three scenarios:
>
> A) monochromatic light shining on a detector for 0.1 seconds
> B) monochromatic light shining on the same size detector for 0.2 seconds
> B) monochromatic light shining on a detector of twice the area of that in
> scenario A, but also for 0.1 seconds
>
> Questions:
>
> How does the total energy received by the detector in case A compare to
> that in case B
> a) A has HALF the energy of case B
> b) A has THE SAME the energy of case B
> b) A has DOUBLE the energy of case B
> Your answer:
>
> How does the total number of photons received by the detector in case A
> compare to that in case B
> a) A has HALF the number of photons as case B
> b) A has THE SAME number of photons as case B
> b) A has DOUBLE number of photons as case B
> Your answer:
>
> How does the total energy received by the detector in case A compare to
> that in case C
> a) A has HALF the energy of case C
> b) A has THE SAME the energy of case C
> b) A has DOUBLE the energy of case C
> Your answer:
>
> How does the total number of photons received by the detector in case A
> compare to that in case C
> a) A has HALF the number of photons as case C
> b) A has THE SAME number of photons as case C
> b) A has DOUBLE number of photons as case C
> Your answer:
>
> And the last question (for now):
>
> What is your formula relating individual photon energy (for monochromatic
> light of frequency f) to planck time (tP)? Please use the symbol E for
> the single photon energy, h for Planck's constant, f for the light
> frequency, and tP for Planck time, and t for time
>
>

Just cross posting to the other groups Porat cross posts to in case he
missed seeing this one.