From: Tim Wescott on
tim.... wrote:
> "Walter Banks" <walter(a)bytecraft.com> wrote in message
> news:4B96B666.65C09F1C(a)bytecraft.com...
>>
>> "tim...." wrote:
>>
>>> "Tim Wescott" <tim(a)seemywebsite.now> wrote in message
>>>> Think engine computers,
>>> does an engine have a computer in it, or is there a computer somewhere in
>>> the car controlling the engine?
>>>
>>> tim
>> Both,
>
> I'm surprised by that answer.
>
> 99.9999% of the time, if one of these deeply embedded processors dies then
> the complete product is scrap.
>
> The idea that you would have to buy (and fit) a completely new engine
> because one of the controlling processors dies just doesn't make sense.

If the engine management computer dies then the engine stops working,
yes. But we're not at the point yet where just because one part of your
car dies you throw away the whole car.

That's because there's this technology that's still not quite dead yet
called "repair". Perhaps you're young and haven't heard of it. You
take your car to someone called a "mechanic"; they figure out which
parts of the car are broken, and they replace them. Car manufacturers
have very cleverly made their cars so that many of the parts are
interchangeable, which means that instead of tossing out the whole car,
your mechanic just tosses out the broken parts, and puts in new ones at
much less than the cost of the whole car.

--
Tim Wescott
Control system and signal processing consulting
www.wescottdesign.com
From: Dennis on
tim.... wrote:
> "Walter Banks" <walter(a)bytecraft.com> wrote in message
> news:4B96B666.65C09F1C(a)bytecraft.com...
>>
>> "tim...." wrote:
>>
>>> "Tim Wescott" <tim(a)seemywebsite.now> wrote in message
>>>> Think engine computers,
>>> does an engine have a computer in it, or is there a computer somewhere in
>>> the car controlling the engine?
>>>
>>> tim
>> Both,
>
> I'm surprised by that answer.
>
> 99.9999% of the time, if one of these deeply embedded processors dies then
> the complete product is scrap.
>
> The idea that you would have to buy (and fit) a completely new engine
> because one of the controlling processors dies just doesn't make sense.
>
> tim
>
>
>
They can replace the computer - about $700-$800 - probably more for
luxury cars
From: Jim Stewart on
Dennis wrote:
> tim.... wrote:
>> "Walter Banks" <walter(a)bytecraft.com> wrote in message
>> news:4B96B666.65C09F1C(a)bytecraft.com...
>>>
>>> "tim...." wrote:
>>>
>>>> "Tim Wescott" <tim(a)seemywebsite.now> wrote in message
>>>>> Think engine computers,
>>>> does an engine have a computer in it, or is there a computer
>>>> somewhere in
>>>> the car controlling the engine?
>>>>
>>>> tim
>>> Both,
>>
>> I'm surprised by that answer.
>>
>> 99.9999% of the time, if one of these deeply embedded processors dies
>> then the complete product is scrap.
>>
>> The idea that you would have to buy (and fit) a completely new engine
>> because one of the controlling processors dies just doesn't make sense.
>>
>> tim
>>
>>
>>
> They can replace the computer - about $700-$800 - probably more for
> luxury cars

I believe the US has a federally mandated 7
year warranty on emissions equipment, which
includes the ECU.
From: ArarghMail003NOSPAM on
On Tue, 09 Mar 2010 14:51:27 -0800, Tim Wescott <tim(a)seemywebsite.now>
wrote:

<snip>
>
>If the engine management computer dies then the engine stops working,
>yes. But we're not at the point yet where just because one part of your
>car dies you throw away the whole car.
>
>That's because there's this technology that's still not quite dead yet
>called "repair". Perhaps you're young and haven't heard of it. You
>take your car to someone called a "mechanic"; they figure out which
>parts of the car are broken, and they replace them. Car manufacturers
>have very cleverly made their cars so that many of the parts are
>interchangeable, which means that instead of tossing out the whole car,
>your mechanic just tosses out the broken parts, and puts in new ones at
>much less than the cost of the whole car.
That presumes that:
a) the "mechanic" can actually identify the broken part, and:
b) a replacement part is actually available.

a) usually happens, but I often have problems with b). Older cars.

The last time I had a problen with b), after a lot of digging around I
found the part on Amazon.com ??? What's a bookseller doing selling
automotive parts??
--
ArarghMail003 at [drop the 'http://www.' from ->] http://www.arargh.com
BCET Basic Compiler Page: http://www.arargh.com/basic/index.html

To reply by email, remove the extra stuff from the reply address.
From: Chris Burrows on
<ArarghMail003NOSPAM(a)NOT.AT.Arargh.com> wrote in message
news:hctdp59et6iehtkcbppte61cl4sue6pkr1(a)4ax.com...
> On Tue, 09 Mar 2010 14:51:27 -0800, Tim Wescott <tim(a)seemywebsite.now>
> What's a bookseller doing selling
> automotive parts??

Why not? My automotive parts dealer sells books ;-)