From: Roger on
I'm always surprised my MacBook Pro goes to sleep at inopportune times,
such as in the middle of an upload (sometimes breaking the upload), in
the middle of recording a video, in the middle of transferring files,
etc. I'd think a modern computer would be smart enough to tell itself,
"hey, I'm uploading a file--now's not a good time to go to sleep."

I can see where this can be set manually in the Energy Saver, but it
seems like my computer should be smart enough to know when it's not a
good idea to go to sleep, dim the screen, etc.

Am I missing anything? Thanks,

Rog

--- news://freenews.netfront.net/ - complaints: news(a)netfront.net ---
From: Lao Ming on
On Mar 5, 6:08 pm, Roger <ro...(a)roger.net> wrote:
> I'm always surprised my MacBook Pro goes to sleep at inopportune times,
> such as in the middle of an upload (sometimes breaking the upload), in
> the middle of recording a video, in the middle of transferring files,
> etc.  I'd think a modern computer would be smart enough to tell itself,
> "hey, I'm uploading a file--now's not a good time to go to sleep."  
>
> I can see where this can be set manually in the Energy Saver, but it
> seems like my computer should be smart enough to know when it's not a
> good idea to go to sleep, dim the screen, etc.
>
> Am I missing anything?  Thanks,
>
> Rog

What's even worse is that Apple can prevent screen grabs while DVD
Player is operating but can't prevent the Screen Saver from
interrupting your movie. Now I could understand if it were one
programmer who just didn't think of it when the software was
introduced but a team of probably more than 50 programmers after
multiple updates of the software?
From: Mike Lane on
Roger wrote on Mar 6, 2010:

> I'm always surprised my MacBook Pro goes to sleep at inopportune times,
> such as in the middle of an upload (sometimes breaking the upload), in
> the middle of recording a video, in the middle of transferring files,
> etc. I'd think a modern computer would be smart enough to tell itself,
> "hey, I'm uploading a file--now's not a good time to go to sleep."
>
> I can see where this can be set manually in the Energy Saver, but it
> seems like my computer should be smart enough to know when it's not a
> good idea to go to sleep, dim the screen, etc.
>
> Am I missing anything? Thanks,
>

I use Caffeine to stop my computer going to sleep when anything critical is
going on. A very useful little utility - it does one thing very efficiently:
http://www.lightheadsw.com/caffeine/

--
Mike Lane
UK North Yorkshire
email: mike_lane at mac dot com

From: Roger on
In article <0001HW.C7B9090800005C32B01029BF(a)news.virginmedia.com>,
Mike Lane <mike.lane.usenet(a)ntlworld.co.uk> wrote:

> Roger wrote on Mar 6, 2010:
>
> > I'm always surprised my MacBook Pro goes to sleep at inopportune times,
> > such as in the middle of an upload (sometimes breaking the upload), in
> > the middle of recording a video, in the middle of transferring files,
> > etc. I'd think a modern computer would be smart enough to tell itself,
> > "hey, I'm uploading a file--now's not a good time to go to sleep."
> >
> > I can see where this can be set manually in the Energy Saver, but it
> > seems like my computer should be smart enough to know when it's not a
> > good idea to go to sleep, dim the screen, etc.
> >
> > Am I missing anything? Thanks,
> >
>
> I use Caffeine to stop my computer going to sleep when anything critical is
> going on. A very useful little utility - it does one thing very efficiently:
> http://www.lightheadsw.com/caffeine/

I'll give it a try. Thanks!

Rog

--- news://freenews.netfront.net/ - complaints: news(a)netfront.net ---
From: Daniel Cohen on
Mike Lane <mike.lane.usenet(a)ntlworld.co.uk> wrote:

> Roger wrote on Mar 6, 2010:
>
> > I'm always surprised my MacBook Pro goes to sleep at inopportune times,
> > such as in the middle of an upload (sometimes breaking the upload), in
> > the middle of recording a video, in the middle of transferring files,
> > etc. I'd think a modern computer would be smart enough to tell itself,
> > "hey, I'm uploading a file--now's not a good time to go to sleep."
> >
> > I can see where this can be set manually in the Energy Saver, but it
> > seems like my computer should be smart enough to know when it's not a
> > good idea to go to sleep, dim the screen, etc.
> >
> > Am I missing anything? Thanks,
> >
>
> I use Caffeine to stop my computer going to sleep when anything critical is
> going on. A very useful little utility - it does one thing very efficiently:
> http://www.lightheadsw.com/caffeine/

Caffeine is neat. A menu bar item that is turned on and off with a
single click. It can also be Applescripted.

Another option is Jiggler. It's a straightforward app, which
preferences, so it can be set to run only when certain apps are running.

Officially Energy Saver sets the machine to sleep after a specified
period during which there is "no keyboard or mouse activity and no hard
drive activity". So in the situations Roger describes Energy Saver
*ought not* to put the machine to sleep, as the hard drive is active
(either reading or writing).

In practice this just doesn't seem to work well for many people, though
others have o trouble.

I've actually had the opposite problem. For some reason (and there have
been various reasons suggested, but I've not been able to find the
cause) my machine just won't sleep. I've used a program that forces
sleep, Please Sleep, to solve this issue. But Please Sleep (and one or
two other programs I've looked at) puts the machine to sleep if there
has been no keyboard or mouse activity for the specified period, even if
the hard drive has been active. So it's the same as Roger's situation,
and I have to use Jiggler or Caffeine to prevent sleep when I want that.
--
<http://www.decohen.com>
Send e-mail to the Reply-To address.
Mail to the From address is never read.