From: Richard Tobin on
In article <1jg409f.l5eb7sr8bgecN(a)de-ster.xs4all.nl>,
J. J. Lodder <jjlxa31(a)xs4all.nl> wrote:

>> Thanks - don't larger disks run hotter though? Is that potentially a problem?

>In principle, no. It's the same amount of disk
>dragged through the air at the same speed.

for a given generation of disks, larger disks have more platters,
which require more energy to start up. They also use a bit more while
running, but the difference will be small - probably less than a watt.

I think the latest 3.5" drives use 500GB platters.

-- Richard
--
Please remember to mention me / in tapes you leave behind.
From: Rob on
On 28/03/2010 20:55, Ian Piper wrote:
> My wife's iMac died a couple of hours ago. At least, the hard disk died.
> I'm pretty sure it's irretrievable: Disk Utility, Disk Warrior, Drive
> Genius and Techtool Pro are unanimous that it's as dead as some
> doo-doos. Between the network and Time Machine we should be OK for
> backups. However, I now need to change the dead 'un for a live 'un.
>
> The disk in my slightly older iMac is a 250 GB Seagate Barracuda. Apart
> from being 320GB IIRC I don't know what the dead disk is. So, two
> questions:
>
> 1. Is replacing the internal hard disk the kind of thing a reasonably
> tech-savvy Mac bod (well, me) can take on?

I managed fine (24 and 27) - got some sucker things off ebay, and a can
of compressed air (to blow the inevitable dust from the screen), and
some decent torx screwdrivers. Be wary of the guides - they get you in
the ballpark, but I've found differences in screw counts/locations.



> 2. Can you recommend a make/model/size of disk suitable for an iMac?
>

I'm pretty sure that all but the latest use a stick-on HD temp sensor.
If it's later, you'll need a disk of the same make with appropriate
pin-outs for the sensor. The 320 in my 24" is the quietest HD I've used,
but it's quite hard to get an exact copy - ebuyer were doing them
rcently I think.

I swapped it out for a 1TB WD 'Green' (lower power, heat and noise) and
it's pretty good. Not quite as good as the 160GB SS :-)

Rob

From: zoara on
Arthur <arthursstuffforsale(a)yahoo.co.uk> wrote:
> I found a bed was the best surface to work on and as usual lots of
> pots and post it notes for the various screws.
>

Fnarr! Second one in this thread, well done.

(though using post-its to make notes about the screws surely kills the
moment?)

-z-


--
email: nettid1 at fastmail dot fm
From: zoara on
Jaimie Vandenbergh <jaimie(a)sometimes.sessile.org> wrote:

> Otherwise, I find Western Digitals very quiet.

Seconded. For me, (lack of) noise is more important than speed or
capacity and I always seem to end up with either Western Digitals or
regrets.

-z-

--
email: nettid1 at fastmail dot fm
From: Chris Ridd on
On 2010-03-30 10:36:44 +0100, zoara said:

> Arthur <arthursstuffforsale(a)yahoo.co.uk> wrote:
>> I found a bed was the best surface to work on and as usual lots of
>> pots and post it notes for the various screws.
>>
>
> Fnarr! Second one in this thread, well done.
>
> (though using post-its to make notes about the screws surely kills the
> moment?)

It depends on where you put it.

--
Chris