From: Paul Hovnanian P.E. on
Joerg wrote:
>
> acannell(a)wwc.com wrote:
> > On Oct 8, 6:03 am, PeterD <pet...(a)hipson.net> wrote:
> >> On Wed, 7 Oct 2009 16:00:41 -0700 (PDT), "acann...(a)wwc.com"
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >> <acann...(a)wwc.com> wrote:
> >>> oh you guys are gonna like this one...
> >>> so i bought a winch for my jeep but it didnt come with a controller
> >>> box.
> >>> so i need a way to connect the 12V from the jeep battery to the winch
> >>> ON and OFF like....and reverse it...so I can reverse the winch
> >>> direction
> >>> thats it!
> >>> needs to be controlled with a rocker switch, or two switches, whatever
> >>> the maximum steady-state current of the winch is about 300A, so the
> >>> switching circuit needs to handle that
> >>> and of course the winch is an enormous DC motor
> >>> so...whats a fun way to do this? bank of mosfets? something else?
> >>> i know i can just by a big relay/contactor, but i want to make this
> >>> myself...
> >>> suggestions?
> >> Go to Warn's site, and download the schematics from one of their winch
> >> controllers, they are simple, using four 'starter relays' of the Ford
> >> variety, a simple switch (SPDT center off), and not much else...
> >>
> >> Resist the urge to go solid-state... Those 'starter relays' are about
> >> $10 each at the parts store.
> >
> > Yeah this is probably the best idea. But I want to go solid state just
> > for fun. Its a neat project dont you think?
>
> Fun? I don't know. But if you implement a proper PWM you could impress
> your friends and tell them "Hey, I can make this huge log move at
> exactly 5ft per minute" :-)

That's not how things work with 4x4s. Its "Hey, I can drag my truck out
of this mudhole which I had no business driving in to begin with at
exactly 5ft per minute."

--
Paul Hovnanian mailto:Paul(a)Hovnanian.com
------------------------------------------------------------------
I love guns. Its bullets that I can't stand.
From: Paul Hovnanian P.E. on
Joerg wrote:
>
> acannell(a)wwc.com wrote:
> > On Oct 8, 6:24 am, George Herold <ggher...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> >> On Oct 7, 7:00 pm, "acann...(a)wwc.com" <acann...(a)wwc.com> wrote:
> >>
> >>
> >>
> >>> oh you guys are gonna like this one...
> >>> so i bought a winch for my jeep but it didnt come with a controller
> >>> box.
> >>> so i need a way to connect the 12V from the jeep battery to the winch
> >>> ON and OFF like....and reverse it...so I can reverse the winch
> >>> direction
> >>> thats it!
> >>> needs to be controlled with a rocker switch, or two switches, whatever
> >>> the maximum steady-state current of the winch is about 300A, so the
> >>> switching circuit needs to handle that
> >>> and of course the winch is an enormous DC motor
> >>> so...whats a fun way to do this? bank of mosfets? something else?
> >>> i know i can just by a big relay/contactor, but i want to make this
> >>> myself...
> >>> suggestions?
> >> 300 amps sems like a lot! I thought the alternator only put out 60A
> >> or so? I guess they put bigger alternators in trucks and such. I've
> >> got a small winch on my truck and just use a big rocker switch.
> >> What's wrong with a even bigger switch? It's simple.
> >>
> >> George H.
> >
> > The battery and the alternator work together to supply the current to
> > the winch.. My winch only draws 30A under no load. But under full load
> > (8000lbs) draws 280A.
> >
> > How big of a rocker switch?? Jeez how often do you use it? Most hand
> > operated switches would not be able to handle winch current.
>
> Well, that depends :-)
>
> http://www.electroswitch.com/electroswitchesandrelays/images/itapSwitch.jpg
>
> You can get switches rated at 1000 amps continuous.

Not suitable for the application. The winch control switch is connected
to the relay box with a 10 foot (or longer) cable. This way the operator
doesn't have to stan next to the winch when that 5/8 inch diam cable
snaps under tension.

--
Paul Hovnanian mailto:Paul(a)Hovnanian.com
------------------------------------------------------------------
politics; n, from the Greek 'poly' meaning many and 'ticks', small
annoying blood suckers.
From: Rich Grise on
On Thu, 08 Oct 2009 10:47:01 -0700, acannell(a)wwc.com wrote:
> On Oct 8, 6:03�am, PeterD <pet...(a)hipson.net> wrote:
>> On Wed, 7 Oct 2009 16:00:41 -0700 (PDT), "acann...(a)wwc.com"
>>
>> >i know i can just by a big relay/contactor, but i want to make this
>> >myself...
>>
>> >suggestions?
>>
>> Go to Warn's site, and download the schematics from one of their winch
>> controllers, they are simple, using four 'starter relays' of the Ford
>> variety, a simple switch (SPDT center off), and not much else...
>>
>> Resist the urge to go solid-state... Those 'starter relays' are about
>> $10 each at the parts store.
>
> Yeah this is probably the best idea. But I want to go solid state just for
> fun. Its a neat project dont you think?

Well, it'll definitely be a learning experience. >:->

BTW, have you figured out the reversing thing yet? If it's a permanent
magnet motor, then you just swap the poles - if it's series wound
(universal), you have to swap either the armature or the field, but
not both.

Personally, I wouldn't bother with a solid-state controller, unless I
wanted to PWM it for torque control.

Good Luck!
Rich

From: Rich Grise on
On Wed, 07 Oct 2009 16:26:57 -0700, Joerg wrote:
>
> As you can see this gets a tad expensive. Also, you need to have some
> safety shut-down feature to cut power when the MOSFETs weld themselves
> shut. Or in case of a contactor if the contacts weld together. After all,
> you don't want the winch to keep cranking and then pulling your Jeep up a
> tree :-)

Aiaiai! Shades of "The Gods Must Be Crazy." (or was that TGMBC II?)

Cheers!
Rich

From: George Herold on
On Oct 8, 7:57 pm, "Paul Hovnanian P.E." <p...(a)hovnanian.com> wrote:
> Joerg wrote:
>
> > acann...(a)wwc.com wrote:
> > > On Oct 8, 6:24 am, George Herold <ggher...(a)gmail.com> wrote:
> > >> On Oct 7, 7:00 pm, "acann...(a)wwc.com" <acann...(a)wwc.com> wrote:
>
> > >>> oh you guys are gonna like this one...
> > >>> so i bought a winch for my jeep but it didnt come with a controller
> > >>> box.
> > >>> so i need a way to connect the 12V from the jeep battery to the winch
> > >>> ON and OFF like....and reverse it...so I can reverse the winch
> > >>> direction
> > >>> thats it!
> > >>> needs to be controlled with a rocker switch, or two switches, whatever
> > >>> the maximum steady-state current of the winch is about 300A, so the
> > >>> switching circuit needs to handle that
> > >>> and of course the winch is an enormous DC motor
> > >>> so...whats a fun way to do this? bank of mosfets? something else?
> > >>> i know i can just by a big relay/contactor, but i want to make this
> > >>> myself...
> > >>> suggestions?
> > >> 300 amps sems like a lot!  I thought the alternator only put out 60A
> > >> or so?  I guess they put bigger alternators in trucks and such.  I've
> > >> got a small winch on my truck and just use a big rocker switch.
> > >> What's wrong with a even bigger switch?  It's simple.
>
> > >> George H.
>
> > > The battery and the alternator work together to supply the current to
> > > the winch.. My winch only draws 30A under no load. But under full load
> > > (8000lbs) draws 280A.
>
> > > How big of a rocker switch?? Jeez how often do you use it? Most hand
> > > operated switches would not be able to handle winch current.
>
> > Well, that depends :-)
>
> >http://www.electroswitch.com/electroswitchesandrelays/images/itapSwit...
>
> > You can get switches rated at 1000 amps continuous.
>
> Not suitable for the application. The winch control switch is connected
> to the relay box with a 10 foot (or longer) cable. This way the operator
> doesn't have to stan next to the winch when that 5/8 inch diam cable
> snaps under tension.
>
> --
> Paul Hovnanian     mailto:P...(a)Hovnanian.com
> ------------------------------------------------------------------
> politics; n, from the Greek 'poly' meaning many and 'ticks', small
> annoying blood suckers.- Hide quoted text -
>
> - Show quoted text -

Mind if I ask another 'stupid' question?
What gauge of cable do you use to run to the box? I've got a left
over hunk of 12 gauge that runs to the rocker switch (60A max, maybe 5
feet of cable). Ahhh the light begins to dawn. You have to mount the
switch on the motor. What are you going to do about water?

George H.