From: Eeyore on


YD wrote:

> Dunno why the 1 uF cap.

German overkill engineering !

Graham

From: Phil Hobbs on
Dave Platt wrote:
>> flywheeling diode and a 1N4007 would do the job just fine. Does the FET
>> source go to ground ? Many power MOSFETS have a diode internally in that
>> orientation across from the source to the drain. It gets there as an
>> integral side effect of the manufacturing process.
>
> Newer designs seem to use a fast-recovery diode (e.g. FRED or HEXFRED
> or HiperFRED) for MOSFET flyback protection. 1N4007s aren't
> particularly fast, and reverse-conduction losses can be significant if
> the switching frequency is high (in e.g. an SMPS). That's probably not
> all that much of an issue in a solenoid driver, though.
>

1N4007s can take a long time to turn _on_ as well as off. You can get
several volts of overshoot in some applications. Definitely not your
ideal catch diode.

Cheers,

Phil Hobbs
From: Arfa Daily on

"Phil Hobbs" <pcdh(a)SpamMeSenseless.pergamos.net> wrote in message
news:45E9C5D0.9080909(a)SpamMeSenseless.pergamos.net...
> Dave Platt wrote:
>>> flywheeling diode and a 1N4007 would do the job just fine. Does the FET
>>> source go to ground ? Many power MOSFETS have a diode internally in that
>>> orientation across from the source to the drain. It gets there as an
>>> integral side effect of the manufacturing process.
>>
>> Newer designs seem to use a fast-recovery diode (e.g. FRED or HEXFRED
>> or HiperFRED) for MOSFET flyback protection. 1N4007s aren't
>> particularly fast, and reverse-conduction losses can be significant if
>> the switching frequency is high (in e.g. an SMPS). That's probably not
>> all that much of an issue in a solenoid driver, though.
>>
>
> 1N4007s can take a long time to turn _on_ as well as off. You can get
> several volts of overshoot in some applications. Definitely not your
> ideal catch diode.
>
> Cheers,
>
> Phil Hobbs

But one that is used by manufacturers world wide for exactly that purpose
....

Arfa


From: Terry Given on
Arfa Daily wrote:
> "Phil Hobbs" <pcdh(a)SpamMeSenseless.pergamos.net> wrote in message
> news:45E9C5D0.9080909(a)SpamMeSenseless.pergamos.net...
>
>>Dave Platt wrote:
>>
>>>>flywheeling diode and a 1N4007 would do the job just fine. Does the FET
>>>>source go to ground ? Many power MOSFETS have a diode internally in that
>>>>orientation across from the source to the drain. It gets there as an
>>>>integral side effect of the manufacturing process.
>>>
>>>Newer designs seem to use a fast-recovery diode (e.g. FRED or HEXFRED
>>>or HiperFRED) for MOSFET flyback protection. 1N4007s aren't
>>>particularly fast, and reverse-conduction losses can be significant if
>>>the switching frequency is high (in e.g. an SMPS). That's probably not
>>>all that much of an issue in a solenoid driver, though.
>>>
>>
>>1N4007s can take a long time to turn _on_ as well as off. You can get
>>several volts of overshoot in some applications. Definitely not your
>>ideal catch diode.
>>
>>Cheers,
>>
>>Phil Hobbs
>
>
> But one that is used by manufacturers world wide for exactly that purpose
> ...
>
> Arfa

so? just because it gets used doesnt mean its suited for the task. think
bell curve....


BTW in that position its probably a 47V zener, clamping the peak drain
voltage.

Cheers
Terry
From: John E. on
Terry Given sez:

> BTW in that position its probably a 47V zener, clamping the peak drain
> voltage.

I'd been turning over in my mind that this is indeed a zener, not simply a
"plain" rectifier. It is indeed a 47 volt zener.

Why was this diode chosen in the design? I'm familiar with the standard diode
being used to short-circuit the back-EMF from the solenoid, but I can't
figure out the purpose of a zener used in this location.

Vdd
/\
|
|
SS
SS Solenoid
SS
|
+-----+
| |
| |
BUZ72 | /---/ ZY47
FET |--+ /\ Diode
-------| |
|--+ |
| |
\ |
0.27R / |
\ |
| |
| |
/// ///

I think that should show proper in Courier or Monaco... or Paris (c:

I must add that Vdd is *reported* to be 42vdc. I was handed this board with
scribbled specs. May be higher or lower or in a parallel universe.

Thanks,
--
John English