Gamma-ray burst could kill off ocean life
in [Physics]
|
From: Sam Wormley on 26 Jul 2010 22:37 On 7/26/10 9:12 PM, Brad Guth wrote: > Astrophysics is changing the rules as we type. Each time something > unusual or weird gets detected, the astrophysics wizards go into > damage-control mode, of obfuscating and/or making up excuses for > whatever covers the most butts. I asked a simple and fair question, Brad: What evidence do you have to support any claim of yours about Sirius B?
From: Sam Wormley on 26 Jul 2010 22:39 On 7/26/10 9:15 PM, Brad Guth wrote: > On Jul 26, 5:59 pm, Sam Wormley<sworml...(a)gmail.com> wrote: >> On 7/26/10 7:22 PM, Brad Guth wrote: >> >>> Astrophysics in currently in the toilet. Far to much doesn't adds up >>> and new stuff keeps getting more weird with nearly every discovery. >> >> Translation: Brad doesn't understand a bit of astrophysics, as is >> documented in his posting record. > > And your infomercial parroting means what exactly? > > Are you suggesting that a trained monkey couldn't do as well as > yourself? > > ~ BG Brad, What evidence do you have to support any claim of yours about Sirius B?
From: Brad Guth on 26 Jul 2010 23:47 On Jul 26, 7:37 pm, Sam Wormley <sworml...(a)gmail.com> wrote: > On 7/26/10 9:12 PM, Brad Guth wrote: > > > Astrophysics is changing the rules as we type. Each time something > > unusual or weird gets detected, the astrophysics wizards go into > > damage-control mode, of obfuscating and/or making up excuses for > > whatever covers the most butts. > > I asked a simple and fair question, Brad: What evidence do you > have to support any claim of yours about Sirius B? As much deductive evidence as anyone else has pertaining to the 65 million year event that terminated most life on Earth. That little impact that most of you want to believe was it, wasn't nearly large enough. Creating the Arctic ocean basin, now that would have been large enough. On the other hand, you seem to think all local stars are passive and planet friendly. ~ BG
From: Sam Wormley on 26 Jul 2010 23:57 On 7/26/10 10:47 PM, Brad Guth wrote: > On Jul 26, 7:37 pm, Sam Wormley<sworml...(a)gmail.com> wrote: >> On 7/26/10 9:12 PM, Brad Guth wrote: >> >>> Astrophysics is changing the rules as we type. Each time something >>> unusual or weird gets detected, the astrophysics wizards go into >>> damage-control mode, of obfuscating and/or making up excuses for >>> whatever covers the most butts. >> >> I asked a simple and fair question, Brad: What evidence do you >> have to support any claim of yours about Sirius B? > > As much deductive evidence as anyone else has pertaining to the 65 > million year event that terminated most life on Earth. > > That little impact that most of you want to believe was it, wasn't > nearly large enough. Creating the Arctic ocean basin, now that would > have been large enough. Show us you calculation that it "wasn't big enough". How do you calculate what is big enough? What is the killing mechanism? > > On the other hand, you seem to think all local stars are passive and > planet friendly. > > ~ BG
From: Brad Guth on 27 Jul 2010 01:22
On Jul 26, 7:39 pm, Sam Wormley <sworml...(a)gmail.com> wrote: > On 7/26/10 9:15 PM, Brad Guth wrote: > > > On Jul 26, 5:59 pm, Sam Wormley<sworml...(a)gmail.com> wrote: > >> On 7/26/10 7:22 PM, Brad Guth wrote: > > >>> Astrophysics in currently in the toilet. Far to much doesn't adds up > >>> and new stuff keeps getting more weird with nearly every discovery. > > >> Translation: Brad doesn't understand a bit of astrophysics, as is > >> documented in his posting record. > > > And your infomercial parroting means what exactly? > > > Are you suggesting that a trained monkey couldn't do as well as > > yourself? > > > ~ BG > > Brad, What evidence do you have to support any claim of yours > about Sirius B? The same evidence that you use to claim there's nothing associating our solar system with Sirius B, any other Sirius star or that of the original molecular cloud that seems to have vanished. A proper computer simulation could demonstrate each of our interpretations, but then you have no idea as to where our solar system was as of 260 million some odd years ago, and you sure as hell can't tell us a damn original thing about Sirius. ~ BG |