From: Chris Ridd on
On 2010-02-10 21:16:32 +0000, John D Groenveld said:

> In article <7tggjaF4miU1(a)mid.individual.net>,
> Chris Ridd <chrisridd(a)mac.com> wrote:
>> Using pca+patchdiag.xref I was only able to get earlier versions of
>> patches marked as recommended and/or security. Typically I could only
>> get version n-1, when version n was current according to
>> pca+patchdiag.xref.
>
> PatchIDs?

The only one I can find right now is 119964-19; patchdiag.xref lists
-20 as being current, and Sunsolve's patchfinder list thinks they're
all available to me. Guess I tried to get -20 slightly too early?

Interestingly the corresponding patch for SPARC is 119963, and *no*
versions of that are accessible without support contracts. Clearly
SPARC users are being treated differently from x86 users.

Neither of these are in the recommended patch clusters according to the
cluster READMEs.

--
Chris

From: Martin Paul on
jimp(a)specsol.spam.sux.com wrote:
> Has anyone else noticed that a lot of patches that used to be public are
> now contract only?
>
> Could this be part of a plan by Oracle to prod people into paying for
> support contracts?

Get ready for some bad news: According to my sources there will be no
more free access to any Solaris patch, be it security or not. A support
contract will be required for every patch download, no matter whether
it's done interactively through the website or hands-off with wget/pca.
I've been told that this policy change won't by publically announced by
Oracle.

It already seems to be in effect. I cannot download any of these patches
with a Sun Online Account which is not connected to a support contract:

Patch IR CR RSB Age Synopsis
------ -- - -- --- --- -------------------------------------------------
119254 52 < 72 RS- 22 SunOS 5.10: Install and Patch Utilities Patch
119255 -- < 72 RS- 22 SunOS 5.10_x86: Install and Patch Utilities Patch
125332 08 = 08 RS- 13 JDS 3: Macromedia Flash Player Plugin Patch
125333 -- < 08 RS- 13 JDS 3_x86: Macromedia Flash Player Plugin Patch
141505 -- < 07 RS- 8 SunOS 5.10_x86: ipf patch
141506 -- < 07 RS- 8 SunOS 5.10: ipf patch

Sooner or later access to patchdiag.xref and all other content currently
on SunSolve will be limited to paying customers as well.

No opinion, but a few thoughts:

Using an operating system where the only way to fix security problems is
waiting for the next version is a no-go, so the minimum cost for running
Solaris on a real-world system is now that of a basic service plan (324$
and up per year).

Sun didn't make enough money, so it's obvious that Oracle handles things
differently. Whether this is a wise decision is left to the future. The
fact that there's no public announcement reveals a lot.

There should be a much simpler way to get basic patch support (think
about a PayPal button at the end of the OS installation to get the
idea). And it definitely should cost less than the service plans.
Personally, I'd prefer a one-time fee for the OS (which should be
included in the price of a server when bought from Sun).

Martin.
--
SysAdmin | Institute of Scientific Computing, University of Vienna
PCA | Analyze, download and install patches for Solaris
| http://www.par.univie.ac.at/solaris/pca/
From: John D Groenveld on
In article <7thmvpFqqmU1(a)mid.individual.net>,
Chris Ridd <chrisridd(a)mac.com> wrote:
>Interestingly the corresponding patch for SPARC is 119963, and *no*
>versions of that are accessible without support contracts. Clearly
>SPARC users are being treated differently from x86 users.

Not sure which BugID in 119964 qualified it as a free patch under
the old policy and whether the bug applies to SPARC.

John
groenveld(a)acm.org
From: John D Groenveld on
In article <4B740876.9030002(a)par.univie.ac.at>,
Martin Paul <map(a)par.univie.ac.at> wrote:
>Get ready for some bad news: According to my sources there will be no
>more free access to any Solaris patch, be it security or not. A support

Thanks for the heads-up.

<URL:http://sunsolve.sun.com/search/document.do?assetkey=1-61-203648-1>
| A support contract covering Solaris is required to access,
| download, install and use all Solaris Software Updates. This
| applies to all Solaris releases.

John
groenveld(a)acm.org
From: Chris Ridd on
On 2010-02-11 16:09:55 +0000, John D Groenveld said:

> In article <4B740876.9030002(a)par.univie.ac.at>,
> Martin Paul <map(a)par.univie.ac.at> wrote:
>> Get ready for some bad news: According to my sources there will be no
>> more free access to any Solaris patch, be it security or not. A support
>
> Thanks for the heads-up.
>
> <URL:http://sunsolve.sun.com/search/document.do?assetkey=1-61-203648-1>
> | A support contract covering Solaris is required to access,
> | download, install and use all Solaris Software Updates. This
> | applies to all Solaris releases.

Hm. Does the word "Update" there refer to major Solaris updates (eg
Solaris 10 update 9) or patches?

--
Chris