Some Contradictory Claims of SR.
in [Relativity]
|
Prev: ben6993 is a LIAR.
Next: Light wave is immaterial
From: Hayek on 13 Jun 2010 03:00 Inertial wrote: > "Hayek" <hayektt(a)nospam.xs4all.nl> wrote in message > news:4c147c04$0$22933$e4fe514c(a)news.xs4all.nl... >> Inertial wrote: >>> "Hayek" <hayektt(a)nospam.xs4all.nl> wrote in message >>> news:4c142d47$0$22920$e4fe514c(a)news.xs4all.nl... >>>> Sam Wormley wrote: >>>>> On 6/11/10 7:19 PM, Hayek wrote: >>>>>> With an absolute frame, the travelling twin stays >>>>>> younger. >>>>> >>>>> There are no absolute frames with special properties! >>>>> >>>> How does light now at what speed to travel ? >>> >>> Why does it need to 'know' anything .. it just does what it does. >> >> With the help of the absolute frame. > > A frame is just a point of view (and which doesn't ahve any special > properties, so does not 'exist' as such).. it cannot DO anything > >> Which is fairly well described in General Relativity, > > Nope .. you clearly don't understand GR or SR. Get an education first And you learned there that "it just does what it does" about the photon. Nein danke. Uwe Hayek. -- We are fast approaching the stage of the ultimate inversion : the stage where the government is free to do anything it pleases, while the citizens may act only by permission; which is the stage of the darkest periods of human history. -- Ayn Rand I predict future happiness for Americans if they can prevent the government from wasting the labors of the people under the pretense of taking care of them. -- Thomas Jefferson. Socialism is a philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy, its inherent virtue is the equal sharing of misery. -- Winston Churchill.
From: Inertial on 13 Jun 2010 03:12 "Hayek" <hayektt(a)nospam.xs4all.nl> wrote in message news:4c14822b$0$22920$e4fe514c(a)news.xs4all.nl... > Inertial wrote: >> "Hayek" <hayektt(a)nospam.xs4all.nl> wrote in message >> news:4c147c04$0$22933$e4fe514c(a)news.xs4all.nl... >>> Inertial wrote: >>>> "Hayek" <hayektt(a)nospam.xs4all.nl> wrote in message >>>> news:4c142d47$0$22920$e4fe514c(a)news.xs4all.nl... >>>>> Sam Wormley wrote: >>>>>> On 6/11/10 7:19 PM, Hayek wrote: >>>>>>> With an absolute frame, the travelling twin stays >>>>>>> younger. >>>>>> >>>>>> There are no absolute frames with special properties! >>>>>> >>>>> How does light now at what speed to travel ? >>>> >>>> Why does it need to 'know' anything .. it just does what it does. >>> >>> With the help of the absolute frame. >> >> A frame is just a point of view (and which doesn't ahve any special >> properties, so does not 'exist' as such).. it cannot DO anything >> >>> Which is fairly well described in General Relativity, >> >> Nope .. you clearly don't understand GR or SR. Get an education first > > And you learned there that "it just does what it does" about the photon. You asked how it knows how to move that fast. It doesn't KNOW anything .. it's a photon. Ask sensible questions. > Nein danke. You get what you ask for
From: eric gisse on 13 Jun 2010 03:14 Hayek wrote: > Inertial wrote: >> "Hayek" <hayektt(a)nospam.xs4all.nl> wrote in message >> news:4c142d47$0$22920$e4fe514c(a)news.xs4all.nl... >>> Sam Wormley wrote: >>>> On 6/11/10 7:19 PM, Hayek wrote: >>>>> With an absolute frame, the travelling twin stays >>>>> younger. >>>> >>>> There are no absolute frames with special properties! >>>> >>> How does light now at what speed to travel ? >> >> Why does it need to 'know' anything .. it just does what it does. > > With the help of the absolute frame. Which is fairly > well described in General Relativity, [...] Making things up is a poor way to win an argument.
From: eric gisse on 13 Jun 2010 03:15 Hayek wrote: > Inertial wrote: >> "Hayek" <hayektt(a)nospam.xs4all.nl> wrote in message >> news:4c147c04$0$22933$e4fe514c(a)news.xs4all.nl... >>> Inertial wrote: >>>> "Hayek" <hayektt(a)nospam.xs4all.nl> wrote in message >>>> news:4c142d47$0$22920$e4fe514c(a)news.xs4all.nl... >>>>> Sam Wormley wrote: >>>>>> On 6/11/10 7:19 PM, Hayek wrote: >>>>>>> With an absolute frame, the travelling twin stays >>>>>>> younger. >>>>>> >>>>>> There are no absolute frames with special properties! >>>>>> >>>>> How does light now at what speed to travel ? >>>> >>>> Why does it need to 'know' anything .. it just does what it does. >>> >>> With the help of the absolute frame. >> >> A frame is just a point of view (and which doesn't ahve any special >> properties, so does not 'exist' as such).. it cannot DO anything >> >>> Which is fairly well described in General Relativity, >> >> Nope .. you clearly don't understand GR or SR. Get an education first > > And you learned there that "it just does what it does" > about the photon. Relativity is not a theory of light. [...]
From: Hayek on 13 Jun 2010 04:14
Inertial wrote: > "Hayek" <hayektt(a)nospam.xs4all.nl> wrote in message > news:4c147cfb$0$22933$e4fe514c(a)news.xs4all.nl... >> Sam Wormley wrote: >>> On 6/12/10 7:58 PM, Hayek wrote: >>>> Sam Wormley wrote: >>>>> On 6/11/10 7:19 PM, Hayek wrote: >>>>>> With an absolute frame, the travelling twin >>>>>> stays younger. >>>>> >>>>> There are no absolute frames with special >>>>> properties! >>>>> >>>> How does light now at what speed to travel ? >>> >>> Light doesn't make a choice-- >> >> Right, it does not have a choice. > > Well derrrr .. how can it make choices? It is light > .. not a sentient being. > >>> it only exists propagating at the cosmic speed >>> limit. >> >> And what makes "the cosmic speed limit" ? > > The way the universe is. Either there is no limit, > or there is a finite limit. I suspect that if there > were no limit. > >> The masses surrounding the photon. > > No .. the local speed of light is always the same at > any point you choose. But if we compare loci, we see that there is a difference, as in Shapiro delay. And then it turns out that mass influences the speed of light. It is only logical that the mass of the universe influences the speed of light. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shapiro_delay Quote by Einstein "In the second place our result shows that, according to the general theory of relativity, the law of the constancy of the velocity of light in vacum, which constitutes one of the two fundamental assumptions in the special theory of relativity and to which we have already frequently referred, cannot claim any unlimited validity. A curvature of rays of light can only take place when the velocity of propagation of light varies with position. Now we might think that as a consequence of this, the special theory of relativity and with it the whole theory of relativity would be laid in the dust. But in reality this is not the case. We can only conclude that the special theory of relativity cannot claim an unlimited domain of validity ; its results hold only so long as we are able to disregard the influences of gravitational fields on the phenomena (e.g. of light)." � Albert Einstein (The General Theory of Relativity: Chapter 22 � A Few Inferences from the General Principle of Relativity) UNQUOTE Le me put it just another way : You agree that a clock runs faster on top of the hill than in the valley. Well, apply einstein : My solution was really for the very concept of time, that is, that time is not absolutely defined but there is an inseparable connection between time and the velocity of light. -- Albert Einstein. So if the clock runs faster on top of the hill, then the light speed is faster at the top of the hill, both seen from the valley, of course. And yet another way : The Earth does a minute amount of frame dragging. But which frame gets dragged ? The frame of the universe, being again in some way referential and preferential. Uwe Hayek. -- We are fast approaching the stage of the ultimate inversion : the stage where the government is free to do anything it pleases, while the citizens may act only by permission; which is the stage of the darkest periods of human history. -- Ayn Rand I predict future happiness for Americans if they can prevent the government from wasting the labors of the people under the pretense of taking care of them. -- Thomas Jefferson. Socialism is a philosophy of failure, the creed of ignorance, and the gospel of envy, its inherent virtue is the equal sharing of misery. -- Winston Churchill. |