From: jim.arnold on
Any of you knowledable people have any experience with PAYG in
Malaysia ?

Daughter going oout there for a month and I want her to have a phone
for emergemcies but worry about her taling her contract phoen oevr
tehre and racking uoa a huge bill. She normally sends 800 texts a
month and receives more !

I want her to leave her normal phone at home and take a PAYG
From: Steve Wyles on
On 23/01/2010 13:41, jim.arnold(a)tesco.net wrote:
> Any of you knowledable people have any experience with PAYG in
> Malaysia ?
>
> Daughter going oout there for a month and I want her to have a phone
> for emergemcies but worry about her taling her contract phoen oevr
> tehre and racking uoa a huge bill. She normally sends 800 texts a
> month and receives more !
>
> I want her to leave her normal phone at home and take a PAYG


She would be better taking an unlocked phone and getting a local payg
sim when she arrives. I'm not aware of any uk networks that have roaming
on payg in malaysia and even then you'd be looking at 30p+ for sending
each sms, receiving is normally free.

Steve
From: David Kennedy on
Steve Wyles wrote:
> On 23/01/2010 13:41, jim.arnold(a)tesco.net wrote:
>> Any of you knowledable people have any experience with PAYG in
>> Malaysia ?
>>
>> Daughter going oout there for a month and I want her to have a phone
>> for emergemcies but worry about her taling her contract phoen oevr
>> tehre and racking uoa a huge bill. She normally sends 800 texts a
>> month and receives more !
>>
>> I want her to leave her normal phone at home and take a PAYG
>
>
> She would be better taking an unlocked phone and getting a local payg
> sim when she arrives. I'm not aware of any uk networks that have roaming
> on payg in malaysia and even then you'd be looking at 30p+ for sending
> each sms, receiving is normally free.

Agreed. Any unlocked phone with a local sim - Maxis for example - will
do the job.

--
David Kennedy

http://www.anindianinexile.com
From: Theo Markettos on
Steve Wyles <steve(a)inhouse.co.uk> wrote:
> She would be better taking an unlocked phone and getting a local payg
> sim when she arrives. I'm not aware of any uk networks that have roaming
> on payg in malaysia and even then you'd be looking at 30p+ for sending
> each sms, receiving is normally free.

It might be worth investigating providers who can do data, then use a Java
app on the phone to send texts - then it's just a few pennies per text plus
the data cost (which should be fairly small, even at extortionate-per-KB).

Trouble is, if she gets a local SIM her friends will be paying 20-30p per
text to send to Malaysia, and those won't be covered by inclusive text
packages. Though they could use Java apps too, it all gets a bit messy.

If you find a network with vaguely sensible data tariffs, how about some
kind of IM solution? I have no idea if such is available at low bandwidth
(and people need to know that sending pictures will really cost $$$).

The easier alternative is to train her not to text so much when she's away
:)

Theo
From: Theo Markettos on
Theo Markettos <theom+news(a)chiark.greenend.org.uk> wrote:
> It might be worth investigating providers who can do data, then use a Java
> app on the phone to send texts - then it's just a few pennies per text plus
> the data cost (which should be fairly small, even at extortionate-per-KB).
>
> Trouble is, if she gets a local SIM her friends will be paying 20-30p per
> text to send to Malaysia, and those won't be covered by inclusive text
> packages. Though they could use Java apps too, it all gets a bit messy.

Another option might be an 'international' roaming SIM... if you get one
with a +44 number from, say, the Isle of Man, that might be covered under
her friends text packages. Texts would probably still be cheaper than 20p,
but still not very cheap.

I just checked 0044's global SIM and to text from Malaysia to UK is 43p.
Ouch! But maybe there are others.

Theo