From: Dave U. Random on
KristleBawl wrote:

> Craig expressed an opinion:
>> On 02/02/2010 10:37 AM, KristleBawl wrote:
>>
>>> The point is that Microsoft freeware is written for Windows users
>>
>> No. Again, IE and other such products aren't freeware.
>>
>> The illustration I posted shows software, published by Microsoft, which
>> may be run on Windows and, via WINE, on Linux and FreeBSD and other
>> OSes. There is no technical barrier. However, you can only install IE
>> "If you are licensed to use Microsoft Windows..."
>>
>> IOW, these are legal restrictions which require(d) payment: i.e. MS
>> Windows license fees. I cannot legally use this software without doing
>> so.
>>
>> This may seem to be inconsequential to you when discussing what is
>> "free" but, in my case, I bought MS Windows so that I could legally use
>> Internet Explorer. Hence, IE is not freeware.
>>
>> fwiw,
>
> I'm not talking about the programs bundled into Windows, such as IE.

Uh, dimbulb... IE *isn't* "bundled into Window$" it's available as a
standalone application. In fact there's a package that actually installs
and configures the official IE package for use under Wine. Much to
Microsloth's chagrin.

*snicker*
From: »Q« on
In <news:Xns9D13B15E65DF9bearbottoms1gmaicom(a)news.albasani.net>,
Bear Bottoms <bearbottoms1(a)gmai.com> wrote:

> To people running Windows the programs are free of any additional
> cost no matter what.

Purchasing a license to run the programs doesn't make them free, it
just makes them already paid for.


From: KristleBawl on
Craig expressed an opinion:
> On 02/02/2010 06:23 PM, KristleBawl wrote:
>> As a Windows user, I cannot install Mac or Linux freeware apps...
>
> Oh yes, you can. Often that's because a lot of their apps are written
> to libraries which are cross-platform. Consider this partial list
> from Wikipedia. GTK apps:
>
> * AbiWord - Word processor

Multi-platform freeware is available for many Operating Systems, not
just windows *or* Mac, etc..

--
Error 216: Tagline out of paper.
KristleBawl's Taglines by Tagzilla 0.066.2
http://xsidebar.mozdev.org/modifiedmailnews.html#tagzilla
Instabird development http://www.instantbird.com/
From: »Q« on
In <news:hlsgm5hdu2d9r068fevplg6k7qrfbauddh(a)4ax.com>,
M.L. <me(a)privacy.invalid> wrote:

> >>> Linux users can also get a lot of programs to work using Wine.
> >>
> >> If it's freeware, that's fine. For a GNU/Linux user to download
> >> and run Microsoft alleged "freeware", s/he'd need to buy a license
> >> for it first.
>
> Freeware is not required to be available for all OS platforms.

For *anyone* to get a license for the alleged freeware, the person
would have to buy that license.

> >> (And even then, MS EULAs generally forbid running their
> >> software on anything other than a licensed MS OS, even if you've
> >> paid for it.)
> >
> >We ran across this issue when we were required by a couple of
> >(large) customers to run Internet Explorer so as to access their
> >supplier databases. There are ways to run IE6 in WINE but, apart
> >from the kludge-factor, the MS EULA requires a valid MSOS license &
> >that it be run on MSOS.
>
> >IE, then, is "free to download" and nothing more. IE still costs $
> >due to the licensing.
>
> EULAs are not legal documents in the USA. More like a preference of
> the distributor.

They *are* legal documents in the USA, though a lot of them contain
provisions that wouldn't be enforceable.
From: Anonymous Remailer (austria) on

Bear Bottoms wrote:

> Craig <netburgher(a)REMOVEgmail.com> wrote in
> news:hkaeg6$vu1$1(a)news.eternal-september.org:
>
>> On 02/02/2010 03:43 PM, KristleBawl wrote:
>>> Craig expressed an opinion:
>>>> On 02/02/2010 02:29 PM, KristleBawl wrote:
>>>>> There are a few programs that you can get for Windows that are free,
>>>>> *after* you already paid for Windows.
>>>>
>>>> Not free. You must pay the MS Windows user's license to run them.
>>>> People happily run all sorts of truly free software apps*, written
>>>> for MS Windows, but in Linux and FreeBSD and others.
>>>>
>>>> That is because these *freeware* writers do not make legal
>>>> requirements that you buy MS Windows.
>>>
>>> Okay, so let me see if I understand you. If I already bought and paid
>>> for genuine Windows OEM on a new computer, then any freeware I install
>>> is only freeware if it is *not* also made by Microsoft?
>>
>> I gave you a perfect example in IE. It is easy to run IE w/o Windows.
>> Microsoft requires you to pay for a Windows license to use IE. Ergo,
>> IE is not freeware.
>>
>> Firefox, Chrome, Safari are all freeware. They do not require the
>> purchase of something to use them.
>>
>> As far as your counter-examples, their EULAs will tell you whether they
>> are freeware: namely, free of any requirement to buy Windows to run
>> them.
>>
>>
> No Craig...simply no. It is freeware. I'll give you a simpler
> example...you buy my radio. I will give you part free of cost to make
> repairs or replacements.

Nope. If you sell someone a package that includes a radio and spare
parts, those parts are LEGALLY part of that transaction and thus have a
monetary value regardless of whatever feel-good blithering you do to try
and convince someone they're getting a "deal".

Most people understand this simple concept Bottoms. Most people aren't so
gullible that they're mislead so badly by a plain and simple line of
bullshit.