From: Elden Fenison on
* Tim McNamara [01/29/10 00:11 UTC]:
> And the cool factor isn't enough for some of us. However, if I was looking
> at an ebook reader type thing this would be top of the list- competitive
> price and better specs than the Kindle and its ilk. And if I can find some
> useful reasons I may just snag one. I'm not convinced I need the 3G aspect,
> WiFi is probable enough for my needs.

My problem is vendor lock in. I already have a Kindle with about 40 books.
Apparently they're staying on the Kindle. I wish for some compatibility
between devices, but that probably won't happen.

--
-=Elden=-
http://www.moondog.org

From: Lloyd Parsons on
In article <slrnhm5flc.7q2.usenet(a)macbook.local>,
Elden Fenison <usenet(a)moondog.org.invalid> wrote:

> * Tim McNamara [01/29/10 00:11 UTC]:
> > And the cool factor isn't enough for some of us. However, if I was looking
> > at an ebook reader type thing this would be top of the list- competitive
> > price and better specs than the Kindle and its ilk. And if I can find some
> > useful reasons I may just snag one. I'm not convinced I need the 3G aspect,
> > WiFi is probable enough for my needs.
>
> My problem is vendor lock in. I already have a Kindle with about 40 books.
> Apparently they're staying on the Kindle. I wish for some compatibility
> between devices, but that probably won't happen.

Currently on the iPhone/Touch for ebooks, there is support for various
ebook formats via some different apps, so the lock in for ebooks isn't
really there at all.

I expect that to remain so, but with the addition of Apple's new ebook
reader and data source.
From: sbt on
In article <slrnhm5flc.7q2.usenet(a)macbook.local>, Elden Fenison
<usenet(a)moondog.org.invalid> wrote:

> * Tim McNamara [01/29/10 00:11 UTC]:
> > And the cool factor isn't enough for some of us. However, if I was looking
> > at an ebook reader type thing this would be top of the list- competitive
> > price and better specs than the Kindle and its ilk. And if I can find some
> > useful reasons I may just snag one. I'm not convinced I need the 3G aspect,
> > WiFi is probable enough for my needs.
>
> My problem is vendor lock in. I already have a Kindle with about 40 books.
> Apparently they're staying on the Kindle. I wish for some compatibility
> between devices, but that probably won't happen.

There is a Kindle app for the iPhone/iTouch and the announcement
strongly implied (some might say "stated") that iTouch apps would be
usable on the iPad. That being the case, I don't see vendor lock-in as
an issue, so long as there is a way to move the content onto the iPad.

--
Spenser
From: John McWilliams on
Dave Allen wrote:
> In article <011b3d65$0$6702$c3e8da3(a)news.astraweb.com>,
> JF Mezei <jfmezei.spamnot(a)vaxination.ca> wrote:
>
>> But the ipAD won't replace coffe table books with high quality images on
>> glossy paper.
>
> That's coming with Apple's planned iTable, a coffee table sized touch
> screen on which you'll be able to slide around several coffee table
> e-books at different orientations.

It damned well better have Firewire! And 4000 x 3000 pixels.

--
john mcwilliam
From: Robert Haar on
On 1/28/10 9:38 PM, "JF Mezei" <jfmezei.spamnot(a)vaxination.ca> wrote:

> Blanche wrote:
>> I'm thinking that many of the active people on this list are not
>> the target market for the iPad. How many people here require a keyboard
>> at leat 60% of the time,
>
>
> The purpose of this device is to expand availability of data/media
> beyond your desktop. You want to read your newspaper/book in bed ? No
> need for a keyboard. Watch a movie ? listen to music ? No need for keyboard.

Agreed. It seems that Apple is targeting a new category of devices that is
between a smart phone and a laptop but is primarily a distribution point for
electronic media and Internet access. It includes some light weight apps but
won't fully replace a laptop/desktop. It is also drop-in-your pocket
replacement for a cell phone. It doesn't really compete with netbooks.

We will have to wait a while to see if it catches on in the marketplace, but
Apple has a pretty job track record in recent years. I haven't decided if I
will get one or not, but if I do, it will be an addition to my current set
of devices, not a replacement.