Gravity is a property of mass - not a property of space !!
in [Relativity]
|
Prev: I was wrong
Next: Prog to transform world lines?
From: mpc755 on 18 Jul 2010 11:53 On Jul 18, 11:33 am, "Y.Porat" <y.y.po...(a)gmail.com> wrote: > On Jul 18, 3:34 pm, mpc755 <mpc... > > the only thing that i could > agree with you if it was > > > > > > no physical entity can move > > > unless it has a free volume top move in > > > even if it is your fucken ETHER > > > > IT CANNOT REPLACE ANOTHER AETHER] > > > > UNLESS THAT 'REPLACED AETHER HAS SOME FREE SPACE TO MOVE IN > > > > IF IT WAS > > > > Aether = Circlons then we haver a start > > > > but that is a completely different Opera > > > > for instance even the Circlon canot move > > > unless it has some free empty place > > > to move in !! > > > if you dont understand that > > > we have no common base to discuss !! > > > ATB > > > and Bye > > > Y.Porat > > > ------------------------ > > > 'Hubble Finds Ghostly Ring of Dark Matter'http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/hubble/news/dark_matter_ring_featur... > > > "Astronomers using NASAs Hubble Space Telescope got a first-hand view > > of how dark matter behaves during a titanic collision between two > > galaxy clusters. The wreck created a ripple of dark matter, which is > > somewhat similar to a ripple formed in a pond when a rock hits the > > water." > > > The ripple is a gravity wave. > > The ripple is displaced dark matter. > > Displaced dark matter is denser than dark matter at rest. > > That does not require space to consist of areas which are a void. > > Dark matter mass is greater where displaced than at rest. > > =============================================------------------ > after you finished your parroting slogans > better start thinking!! > iow > before knowing to run > learn firt to crawl > > i was asking you if there is complete empty space > and you dont answers reasonable > > since you admitetd that dark matter or matter > **has mass* > you should know and understand a bsic rule in physics > that unfortunately is not thought at schools > > a mass can not do any action if it cant move > even a billionth of a nanometer !! > if it has no possibility to move one billionth of a manometer ----- > --IT CANNOT DO ANY ACTION!! > > NO MOVEMENT - NO ACTION!! > > AND ***NO EMPTY SPACE*** FOR IT > **EVEN A TINNY EMPTY SPACE**!! - > ---IT CANNOT MOVE !! > got it?? > if not go discuss with someone else > not with me > > BYE > Y.Porat > -------------------- 'Hubble Finds Ghostly Ring of Dark Matter' http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/hubble/news/dark_matter_ring_feature.html "Astronomers using NASAs Hubble Space Telescope got a first-hand view of how dark matter behaves during a titanic collision between two galaxy clusters. The wreck created a ripple of dark matter, which is somewhat similar to a ripple formed in a pond when a rock hits the water." The ripple is a gravity wave. The ripple is displaced dark matter. Displaced dark matter is denser than dark matter at rest. That does not require space to consist of areas which are a void. Dark matter mass is greater where displaced than at rest. The mass of the dark matter which exists outside of two objects is greater then the mass of the dark matter which exists between two objects. The Casimir Effect is caused by dark matter which exists outside of the plates which is displaced by the plates forcing the plates together. 'Casimir effect' http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casimir_effect#Vacuum_energy "In a simplified view, a "field" in physics may be envisioned as if space were filled with interconnected vibrating balls and springs, and the strength of the field can be visualized as the displacement of a ball from its rest position." The strength of the field is the displacement of the dark matter from its rest position.
From: Y.Porat on 18 Jul 2010 23:26 On Jul 18, 5:53 pm, mpc755 <mpc...(a)gmail.com> wrote: > On Jul 18, 11:33 am, "Y.Porat" <y.y.po...(a)gmail.com> wrote: > > > > > On Jul 18, 3:34 pm, mpc755 <mpc... > > the only thing that i could > > agree with you if it was > > > > > no physical entity can move > > > > unless it has a free volume top move in > > > > even if it is your fucken ETHER > > > > > IT CANNOT REPLACE ANOTHER AETHER] > > > > > UNLESS THAT 'REPLACED AETHER HAS SOME FREE SPACE TO MOVE IN > > > > > IF IT WAS > > > > > Aether = Circlons then we haver a start > > > > > but that is a completely different Opera > > > > > for instance even the Circlon canot move > > > > unless it has some free empty place > > > > to move in !! > > > > if you dont understand that > > > > we have no common base to discuss !! > > > > ATB > > > > and Bye > > > > Y.Porat > > > > ------------------------ > > > > 'Hubble Finds Ghostly Ring of Dark Matter'http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/hubble/news/dark_matter_ring_featur... > > > > "Astronomers using NASAs Hubble Space Telescope got a first-hand view > > > of how dark matter behaves during a titanic collision between two > > > galaxy clusters. The wreck created a ripple of dark matter, which is > > > somewhat similar to a ripple formed in a pond when a rock hits the > > > water." > > > > The ripple is a gravity wave. > > > The ripple is displaced dark matter. > > > Displaced dark matter is denser than dark matter at rest. > > > That does not require space to consist of areas which are a void. > > > Dark matter mass is greater where displaced than at rest. > > > =============================================------------------ > > after you finished your parroting slogans > > better start thinking!! > > iow > > before knowing to run > > learn firt to crawl > > > i was asking you if there is complete empty space > > and you dont answers reasonable > > > since you admitetd that dark matter or matter > > **has mass* > > you should know and understand a bsic rule in physics > > that unfortunately is not thought at schools > > > a mass can not do any action if it cant move > > even a billionth of a nanometer !! > > if it has no possibility to move one billionth of a manometer ----- > > --IT CANNOT DO ANY ACTION!! > > > NO MOVEMENT - NO ACTION!! > > > AND ***NO EMPTY SPACE*** FOR IT > > **EVEN A TINNY EMPTY SPACE**!! - > > ---IT CANNOT MOVE !! > > got it?? > > if not go discuss with someone else > > not with me > > > BYE > > Y.Porat > > -------------------- > > 'Hubble Finds Ghostly Ring of Dark Matter'http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/hubble/news/dark_matter_ring_featur... > > "Astronomers using NASAs Hubble Space Telescope got a first-hand view > of how dark matter behaves during a titanic collision between two > galaxy clusters. The wreck created a ripple of dark matter, which is > somewhat similar to a ripple formed in a pond when a rock hits the > water." > > The ripple is a gravity wave. > The ripple is displaced dark matter. > Displaced dark matter is denser than dark matter at rest. > That does not require space to consist of areas which are a void. > Dark matter mass is greater where displaced than at rest. > > The mass of the dark matter which exists outside of two objects is > greater then the mass of the dark matter which exists between two > objects. > > The Casimir Effect is caused by dark matter which exists outside of > the plates which is displaced by the plates forcing the plates > together. > > 'Casimir effect'http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casimir_effect#Vacuum_energy > > "In a simplified view, a "field" in physics may be envisioned as if > space were filled with interconnected vibrating balls and springs, and > the strength of the field can be visualized as the displacement of a > ball from its rest position." > > The strength of the field is the displacement of the dark matter from > its rest position. ===================== so Mr Parrot ?????!!! in order of making displacement from its rest position needs some empty space or not ?? 2 quote: "In a simplified view, a "field" in physics may be envisioned as if > space were filled with interconnected vibrating balls and springs, and > the strength of the field can be visualized as the displacement of a > ball from its rest position." end of quote!! -------- so how about some **further conclusions** about that quote?? for instance if it is filles with vibrating springs and balles can a spring Vibrate ---- --if it has no some empty space to vibrate in it ??!! iow just take endles number of springs fill the whole universe withe suchsprings touching eachother with no some empty space between them can they vibrate in such a situation??!! do you know what is vibration is ??!! did you ever see a violin of a guitar in which the strings are sicked all together ??!! it seems that you never played a violin .. or a guitar . (:-) btw even to amke some sound in our air there is need to have some empty space between the molecules of air!!! or even** INSIDE THE MOLECULES **!!! or else they cannot be compressed or decompressed !! the same with your Aether:: it cannoT be compressed or decompressed if not having some empty space between them the sonner you will realize it ---THE BETTER !! (it is not such a big a shame to learn from Y.Porat something in physics ...) ATB Y.Porat ------------------------- does someone need to be a genious in order to understand it ??!!
From: mpc755 on 19 Jul 2010 00:40 On Jul 18, 11:26 pm, "Y.Porat" <y.y.po...(a)gmail.com> wrote: > On Jul 18, 5:53 pm, mpc755 <mpc...(a)gmail.com> wrote: > > > On Jul 18, 11:33 am, "Y.Porat" <y.y.po...(a)gmail.com> wrote: > > > > On Jul 18, 3:34 pm, mpc755 <mpc... > > the only thing that i could > > > agree with you if it was > > > > > > no physical entity can move > > > > > unless it has a free volume top move in > > > > > even if it is your fucken ETHER > > > > > > IT CANNOT REPLACE ANOTHER AETHER] > > > > > > UNLESS THAT 'REPLACED AETHER HAS SOME FREE SPACE TO MOVE IN > > > > > > IF IT WAS > > > > > > Aether = Circlons then we haver a start > > > > > > but that is a completely different Opera > > > > > > for instance even the Circlon canot move > > > > > unless it has some free empty place > > > > > to move in !! > > > > > if you dont understand that > > > > > we have no common base to discuss !! > > > > > ATB > > > > > and Bye > > > > > Y.Porat > > > > > ------------------------ > > > > > 'Hubble Finds Ghostly Ring of Dark Matter'http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/hubble/news/dark_matter_ring_featur... > > > > > "Astronomers using NASAs Hubble Space Telescope got a first-hand view > > > > of how dark matter behaves during a titanic collision between two > > > > galaxy clusters. The wreck created a ripple of dark matter, which is > > > > somewhat similar to a ripple formed in a pond when a rock hits the > > > > water." > > > > > The ripple is a gravity wave. > > > > The ripple is displaced dark matter. > > > > Displaced dark matter is denser than dark matter at rest. > > > > That does not require space to consist of areas which are a void. > > > > Dark matter mass is greater where displaced than at rest. > > > > =============================================------------------ > > > after you finished your parroting slogans > > > better start thinking!! > > > iow > > > before knowing to run > > > learn firt to crawl > > > > i was asking you if there is complete empty space > > > and you dont answers reasonable > > > > since you admitetd that dark matter or matter > > > **has mass* > > > you should know and understand a bsic rule in physics > > > that unfortunately is not thought at schools > > > > a mass can not do any action if it cant move > > > even a billionth of a nanometer !! > > > if it has no possibility to move one billionth of a manometer ----- > > > --IT CANNOT DO ANY ACTION!! > > > > NO MOVEMENT - NO ACTION!! > > > > AND ***NO EMPTY SPACE*** FOR IT > > > **EVEN A TINNY EMPTY SPACE**!! - > > > ---IT CANNOT MOVE !! > > > got it?? > > > if not go discuss with someone else > > > not with me > > > > BYE > > > Y.Porat > > > -------------------- > > > 'Hubble Finds Ghostly Ring of Dark Matter'http://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/hubble/news/dark_matter_ring_featur... > > > "Astronomers using NASAs Hubble Space Telescope got a first-hand view > > of how dark matter behaves during a titanic collision between two > > galaxy clusters. The wreck created a ripple of dark matter, which is > > somewhat similar to a ripple formed in a pond when a rock hits the > > water." > > > The ripple is a gravity wave. > > The ripple is displaced dark matter. > > Displaced dark matter is denser than dark matter at rest. > > That does not require space to consist of areas which are a void. > > Dark matter mass is greater where displaced than at rest. > > > The mass of the dark matter which exists outside of two objects is > > greater then the mass of the dark matter which exists between two > > objects. > > > The Casimir Effect is caused by dark matter which exists outside of > > the plates which is displaced by the plates forcing the plates > > together. > > > 'Casimir effect'http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casimir_effect#Vacuum_energy > > > "In a simplified view, a "field" in physics may be envisioned as if > > space were filled with interconnected vibrating balls and springs, and > > the strength of the field can be visualized as the displacement of a > > ball from its rest position." > > > The strength of the field is the displacement of the dark matter from > > its rest position. > > ===================== > so Mr Parrot ?????!!! > in order of making displacement from its rest position > needs some empty space or not ?? Dark matter displacement does not require there to be a areas of space which are void of mass. > 2 > quote: > "In a simplified view, a "field" in physics may be envisioned as if> space were filled with interconnected vibrating balls and springs, and > > the strength of the field can be visualized as the displacement of a > > ball from its rest position." > The strength of the field is the displacement of dark matter from its rest position. > end of quote!! > -------- > so > how about some **further conclusions** > about that quote?? > for instance > if it is filles with vibrating springs and balles > > can a spring Vibrate ---- > > --if it has no some empty space to vibrate in it ??!! > iow > just take endles number of springs > fill the whole universe withe suchsprings > touching eachother > with no some empty space between them > can they vibrate in such a situation??!! > do you know what is vibration is ??!! > > did you ever see a violin of a guitar > in which the strings are sicked all together ??!! > > it seems that you never played a violin .. > or a guitar . (:-) > btw > even to amke some sound in our air > there is need to have some empty space between the molecules of air!!! > or even** INSIDE THE MOLECULES **!!! > or else they cannot be compressed or decompressed !! > > the same with your Aether:: > it cannoT be compressed or decompressed if not > having some empty space between them > > the sonner you will realize it > ---THE BETTER !! > (it is not such a big a shame to learn from Y.Porat > something in physics ...) > > ATB > Y.Porat > ------------------------- > > does someone need to be a genious in order to understand it ??!!
From: Y.Porat on 19 Jul 2010 05:34 On Jul 19, 6:35 a MPC > agree. The aetherists think there is a 'material' other than matter > that fills space, but this doesn't stop matter from moving around. In > either case (aether or no aether) there is no matter there. So yes, > matter can move. > > That does NOT mean that empty space doesn't have any properties at all > (it has volume, for a start) -------------- i amnot sure you went to the depth of my assertion that the fact that there is movement is a prove that THAT THERE IS AND MUST BE A 100 PERCENT EMPTY SPACE !!! IT IS REALLY NOT WRITTEN UN ANY EXISTING TEXT BOOK it is a brand new insight 1 even if very simple but not trivial !! in order to undertsnd it you must 'zoon' inner and inner to the structure of matter !! you can say for instance that ok i understand that a cannon bullet does not care much if there is air in space or not becuase it has little effect on it but now lets zoon a step inner: you can say of k there is aire in space but its movement is not affected by say the EM waves do does it mean that if there is EM waves space does not have completely empty parts in it ?? so letes zoom even inner we now that em waves move now MPC will come and say it can move because darkmstetr there or his Aether rgwee is very diluted and has very stiny mass but in spight of it s[ace is not empty- it has dark matetr ok fine let s now zoom in even further one can say dark matter can move because ??? becaus of what if dark matetr was finning co,pletely all space withno empty space of it at all?? how can it move if there is darm matter all around it ?? will it penetrate to another dark matter ?? if your neighbor dark matter is pushed by you were should it move to ?? th eneinour of your neighbor i s srtong and massive and mighty as you youself why AND HOW ? should it give up its place ?? even if it 'would like to give up its palce no other dark matter all around it is able enabled to'gine uo its palce !! so you see that no matter how deep you zoo into matter each level of matter density of mas size has its limits of 'giving up its palce UNLESS?? UNLESS WHAT ???!! unless a very simple rock solid conclusion !! can you guess what is that mathematical like prove ??!! BTW i agree with you taht empty space has volume!! iow can host mass!! yet you say it is a nice beginning?? i say it is a nice ??----- FULL STOP !!! (or else there is no motion in our universe )) 9because if the most primitive satte ot [hysical entity has no empty space to move it wil not let the secondary over primitive entity to move ETC ETC ETC !!! ATB may be someone could phrase it better than my poor explanation ability yet as far as i know it is the original !! so copyright insight and explanation Yehiel Porat July 2010 -------------------------- -----------------------
From: ben6993 on 19 Jul 2010 09:35
On Jul 19, 10:34 am, "Y.Porat" <y.y.po...(a)gmail.com> wrote: > On Jul 19, 6:35 a MPC > > > agree. The aetherists think there is a 'material' other than matter > > that fills space, but this doesn't stop matter from moving around. In > > either case (aether or no aether) there is no matter there. So yes, > > matter can move. > > > That does NOT mean that empty space doesn't have any properties at all > > (it has volume, for a start) > > -------------- > i amnot sure you went to the depth of my assertion that > the fact that there is movement > is a prove that > > THAT THERE IS AND MUST BE A 100 PERCENT EMPTY SPACE !!! > IT IS REALLY NOT WRITTEN UN ANY EXISTING TEXT BOOK > it is a brand new insight 1 > even if very simple but > not trivial !! > in order to undertsnd it > you must 'zoon' inner and inner > to the structure of matter !! > > you can say for instance that > ok i understand that > a cannon bullet does not care much > if there is air in space or not > becuase it has little effect on it > but now > lets zoon a step inner: > you can say > of k there is aire in space > but its movement is not affected by say > the EM waves > do does it mean that if there is EM waves > space does not have completely empty parts in it ?? > so letes zoom even inner > > we now that em waves move > now MPC will come and say > it can move because darkmstetr there > or his Aether rgwee is very diluted > and has very stiny mass > but in spight of it s[ace is not empty- > it has dark matetr > ok fine > let s now zoom in even further > one can say > dark matter can move because ??? > becaus of what > if dark matetr was finning co,pletely > all space withno empty space of it > at all?? > how can it move if there is darm matter all around it ?? > will it penetrate to another dark matter ?? > if your neighbor dark matter is pushed > by you > were should it move to ?? > th eneinour of your neighbor > i s srtong and massive and mighty as you youself > why AND HOW ? > should it give up its place ?? > even if it 'would like to give up its palce > no other dark matter all around it > is able enabled to'gine uo its palce !! > > so you see that no matter how deep you zoo into matter > each level of matter density of mas size > has its limits of 'giving up its palce > UNLESS?? > > UNLESS WHAT ???!! > unless a very simple rock solid conclusion !! > can you guess what is that > mathematical like prove ??!! > BTW > i agree with you taht empty space > has volume!! > iow > can host mass!! > yet you say it is a nice beginning?? > > i say > it is a nice ??----- FULL STOP !!! > > (or else there is no motion in our universe )) > 9because if the most primitive satte > ot [hysical entity > has no empty space to move > it wil not let the secondary over primitive > entity to move > ETC ETC ETC !!! > > ATB > may be someone could phrase it better than my poor explanation > ability > yet as far as i know it is the original !! > so > copyright insight and explanation > > Yehiel Porat > July 2010 > -------------------------- > ----------------------- > may be someone could phrase it better than my poor explanation ability > yet as far as i know it is the original !! Over the last six months you have implied "no physics without length", also: "no physics without time". That followed from you diasagreeing with quantum theory assumptions of instantaneous emmission and the existence of point particles. Next you explicitly say: "no physics without mass". That covers all three dimensions of a dimensional analysis: M, L and T. (By the way, I did not agree with your dimensional analysis comments as you thought they required specific units.) You have also explicitly said about six months ago something like: no physics without movement. Now you are saying: "no physics without empty space" and you claim it as your original idea. So for "physics" you imply that M, L, T, void and movement are needed? Have I left anything out? |